AFTER THE HISTORY OF SEXUALITY
German Genealogies with and Beyond Foucault
Edited by Scott Spector, Helmut Puff, and Dagmar Herzog
ISBN 978-0-85745-373-0 $95.00/£60.00 Hb Published (July 2012)
ISBN 978-0-85745-937-4 $29.95/£18.75 Pb Published (July 2012)
eISBN 978-0-85745-374-7 eBook
“The ability to go back to and beyond Foucault seems to be genuinely liberating [as shown] in this excellent collection of essays—ranging in period from the medieval to the twentieth century…This new focus on resistance as well as on discipline, and on milieux as well as on discourses, is highly refreshing. The authors are to be commended for their bold and self-critical venture. They open up the possibility of a less reverential, but more complex and insightful assessment of Foucault’s work. It is pleasing to see German historiography at the head of this exciting new trend.” · German History
“This is an important collection of essays, many of them very original and outstanding, that will further the field of history of sexuality in general and will contribute to the German historiography in particular.” · Lutz Sauerteig, University of Durham
"This volume provides a thought provoking and thorough engagement with various aspects of Foucault’s writing, at once paying homage to core themes in the history of German sexuality and charting a course for future research…The organization, structure, and coherence of each section is very strong…Most intriguing is its blend of approaches and blurring of time, distance (the Atlantic divide in scholarship, that is), and disciplinarity." · Jennifer Evans, Carleton University
Michel Foucault’s seminal The History of Sexuality (1976–1984) has since its publication provided a context for the emergence of critical historical studies of sexuality. This collection reassesses the state of the historiography on sexuality—a field in which the German case has been traditionally central. In many diverse ways, the Foucauldian intervention has governed the formation of questions in the field as well as the assumptions about how some of these questions should be answered. It can be argued, however, that some of these revolutionary insights have ossified into dogmas or truisms within the field. Yet, as these contributions meticulously reveal, those very truisms, when revisited with a fresh eye, can lead to new, unexpected insights into the history of sexuality, necessitating a return to and reinterpretation of Foucault’s richly complex work. This volume will be necessary reading for students of historical sexuality as well as for those readers in German history and German studies generally who have an interest in the history of sexuality.
Scott Spector is Professor in the Department of History and Professor and Chair of Germanic Languages and Literatures at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Helmut Puff is Professor in the Departments of History and Germanic Languages at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Dagmar Herzog is Distinguished Professor of History and Daniel Rose Faculty Scholar at the Graduate Center, City University of New York.
LC: HQ76.3.G4A38 2012BISAC: HIS054000 HISTORY/Social History; SOC032000 SOCIAL SCIENCE/Gender Studies; HIS014000 HISTORY/Europe/GermanyBIC: HBTB Social & cultural history; JFSJ Gender studies, gender groups
List of Figures
Introduction: After the History of Sexuality? Periodicities, Subjectivities, Ethics
PART I: WHEN WAS SEXUALITY? RETHINKING PERIODIZATION
Chapter 1. After the History of (Male) Homosexuality
Chapter 2. Sexual Identity and Other Aspects of ‘Modern’ Sexuality: New Chronologies, Same Old Problem?
Chapter 3. Interior States and Sexuality in Early Modern Germany
Chapter 4. Saying It With Flowers: Post-Foucauldian Literary History and the Poetics of Taboo in a Premodern German Love Song (Walther von der Vogelweide’s Under der linden)
Chapter 5. Early Nineteenth-Century Sexual Radicalism: Heinrich Hössli and the Liberals of His Day
Robert Deam Tobin
PART II: WHOSE SEXUALITY? SUBJECTIVITY, SURVEILLANCE, EMANCIPATION
Chapter 6. Anna Rüling, Michel Foucault, and the ‘Tactical Polyvalence’ of the Female Homosexual
Chapter 7. To Police and Protect: The Surveillance of Homosexuality in Imperial Berlin
Chapter 8. Soliciting Fantasies: Knowing and Not-Knowing about Male Prostitution by Soldiers in Imperial Germany
Chapter 9. Between Normalization and Resistance: Prostitutes’ Professional Identities and Political Organization in Weimar Germany
Chapter 10. Writing Love, Feeling Shame: Rethinking Respectability in the Weimar Homosexual Women’s Movement
Chapter 11. Transsexual: Herculine Barbin Meets ‘Liebe Marta
PART III: THE POLITICS OF SEXUAL ETHICS
Chapter 12. Beyond Freedom: A Return to Subjectivity in the History of Sexuality
Chapter 13. Homosexuality in the Sexual Ethics of the 1930s: A Values Debate in the Culture Warsbetween Conservatism, Liberalism, and Moral-National Renewal
Chapter 14. Socialist Eugenics and Homosexuality in the GDR: The Case of Günter Dörner
Florian G. Mildenberger
Chapter 15. Sex, Sentiment, and Socialism: Relationship Counseling in the GDR in the Wake of the 1965 Family Law Code
Chapter 16. Longing, Lust, Violence, Liberation: Discourses on Sexuality on the Radical Left in West Germany, 1969-1972
Postscript: Tomorrow Sex Will Be Good Again